
Renting vs. Buying: Edgar Ibarra on Rising Rents, Zillow Demand Data, and Your Next 3 to 5 Years
Renting Feels Cheaper Until You See This
Edgar Ibarra says renting can feel like the cheaper choice, at least until you look at what is happening in the rental market. A new Zillow report found that rental demand jumped about 19% over the past year, driven in part by buyers who are sitting out the purchase market. More people competing for rentals can put upward pressure on prices, which is exactly what the data shows. Figures vary by market, so local conditions matter.
Rent Is Not Standing Still
According to the report Edgar references, the typical rent rose again in September, marking the fifth straight month of faster growth. For renters, that can mean a bigger monthly bill at the next lease renewal. Unlike a fixed rate mortgage payment of principal and interest, rent can reset higher with each new lease, which makes long-term budgeting harder.
Renting Can Still Be the Right Move
Edgar is clear that renting can absolutely be the right choice for a season of life. It offers flexibility, and it works especially well if you are intentionally saving the difference between your rent and what you might spend on a home. The key word is intentional. Money set aside on purpose for a down payment, reserves, or other goals can turn a rental period into a strategy rather than a delay.
What Rent Doesn’t Build
The tradeoff is that rent builds your landlord’s equity rather than your own. Homeowners with a mortgage pay down principal over time and may benefit from appreciation, though home values are never guaranteed to rise. Owners also take on costs renters do not, including property taxes, insurance, maintenance, and repairs, so a fair comparison looks at the full cost of ownership and not just the mortgage payment.
Ask a Better Question
Edgar suggests that the question is not whether you should rent or buy forever. It is what your next three to five years look like. If you expect to stay put for several years, ownership may make more financial sense. If you may move soon or your plans are uncertain, renting may be the better fit. Your timeline, savings, and goals should guide the decision.
See the Comparison Side by Side
If you are weighing the two, Edgar Ibarra will compare your current rent to a real ownership payment, side by side, so you can see the difference in black and white. Reach out to Edgar to run your numbers.
Sources
Zillow.com
NAR.realtor
ConsumerFinancialProtectionBureau.gov
FreddieMac.com
HUD.gov


